E. Jean Carroll vs. Trump in 2026: Verdicts, Appeals and the DOJ Probe Explained

New details in the E. Jean Carroll probe - Nexgen Headlines
File photo. Photo: Unknown / CC BY-SA 3.0 / Wikimedia Commons.
Saroj Mali
Saroj Mali - Senior Editor

Updated Oct. 26, 2026: rewritten as a full explainer on where E. Jean Carroll’s cases against Donald Trump stand, including the Supreme Court’s June ruling, the pending $83.3 million appeal and the Justice Department probe reported in May.

Quick answer: As of Oct. 26, 2026, Carroll’s $5 million verdict is final. The Supreme Court refused to hear Trump’s appeal on June 29, 2026, and Carroll was reported to have collected about $5.6 million with interest. The separate $83.3 million defamation verdict was upheld by a federal appeals court, and Trump asked the Supreme Court to review it in late July. That petition is still pending. A Justice Department inquiry reported in May focuses on a nonprofit tied to Reid Hoffman that helped pay Carroll’s legal bills. Chicago’s U.S. attorney said reports that his office was investigating Carroll herself were false. No charges have been reported.

- Advertisement -

The story has several moving parts that are easy to mix up. Here’s each one, in order.

The two cases at a glance

Case 1: sexual abuse and defamationCase 2: defamation
Jury verdict$5 million (May 2023)$83.3 million (January 2024)
What the jury foundTrump sexually abused Carroll in the 1990s and defamed her in 2022Trump defamed Carroll with statements he made as president in 2019
Appeals courtUpheld by the 2nd CircuitUpheld by the 2nd Circuit
Supreme CourtDeclined to hear it, June 29, 2026Petition filed late July 2026; pending
StatusFinal; reported paid with interestOn hold pending the Supreme Court; Trump posted a bond of about $91.6 million in 2024

Trump has always denied Carroll’s accusations and says the cases are politically motivated.

E. Jean Carroll

Timeline of the Carroll cases

DateWhat happened
June 2019Carroll publicly accuses Trump of assaulting her in a New York department store in the mid-1990s. Trump, then president, denies it and says he doesn’t know her.
Nov. 2019Carroll sues Trump for defamation over those 2019 statements (this becomes Case 2).
Nov. 2022She files a second suit under New York’s Adult Survivors Act, adding a battery claim and newer statements (Case 1).
May 9, 2023A jury finds Trump liable for sexual abuse and defamation and awards $5 million.
Jan. 26, 2024A second jury awards $83.3 million for the 2019 statements.
Dec. 2024The 2nd Circuit upholds the $5 million verdict.
Sept. 2025The 2nd Circuit upholds the $83.3 million verdict.
Late May 2026News outlets report a Justice Department inquiry linked to funding of Carroll’s lawsuits.
June 29, 2026The Supreme Court declines to hear Trump’s appeal of the $5 million verdict.
Late July 2026Trump, backed by the Justice Department, asks the Supreme Court to review the $83.3 million verdict.

What the Supreme Court did, and what’s still pending

The justices turned away the $5 million appeal on June 29 without explanation, which is normal for these orders. That left the verdict in place. Carroll’s lawyers have said it can no longer be challenged.

The bigger fight is over the $83.3 million award. Bloomberg Law reported that Trump’s July petition leans on presidential immunity: he argues his statements about Carroll were made while he was in office, as part of his job.

The Justice Department also urged the Court to take the case. It argues that under a federal law called the Westfall Act, the U.S. government should have replaced Trump as the defendant. If that happened, the case would likely end, because the federal government can’t be sued for defamation. The 2nd Circuit rejected that argument.

The Court’s new term began in October. It could decide whether to hear the case at any of its private conferences this fall or winter. Most petitions are denied.

Also read: Supreme Court Birthright Citizenship Ruling: What It Means for Families

The Justice Department probe: what was reported

In late May 2026, Reuters and other outlets reported that the U.S. attorney’s office in Chicago was looking at American Future Republic, a nonprofit backed by LinkedIn co-founder Reid Hoffman. The group helped pay some of Carroll’s legal bills.

  • What investigators reportedly examined: possible money laundering, conspiracy and obstruction connected to the nonprofit, according to CBS News and Reuters.
  • Carroll’s deposition: Reports said prosecutors were also looking at what Carroll said in a 2022 deposition about outside funding for her case.
  • The denial: Andrew Boutros, the U.S. attorney in Chicago, said his office had not opened a criminal investigation into Carroll. CBS News updated its report to say she was not the target.
  • Hoffman’s response: Hoffman called the scrutiny false and said it was meant to silence Trump’s critics.
  • Stage: CNN described the inquiry as early. As of Oct. 26, no charges against anyone had been reported.

Why the funding question matters

Trump’s lawyers had raised the funding issue in his appeals. They argued Carroll hid outside support when she said in her deposition that no one else was paying her legal costs.

The 2nd Circuit didn’t accept that argument. It said Carroll could plausibly have forgotten about limited outside funding. Hoffman has said his support came after the lawsuit was already filed.

So the probe and the verdicts are separate tracks. Even if prosecutors pursued someone over the funding, that wouldn’t automatically undo a jury verdict. A court would have to reopen the case.

Who decides what happens next

DecisionWho makes it
Whether to hear the $83.3 million appealThe U.S. Supreme Court (four justices must agree)
Whether the U.S. government replaces Trump as defendantThe courts, on the Justice Department’s Westfall Act argument
Whether anyone is charged over the nonprofit fundingFederal prosecutors and, if charges come, a grand jury
When Carroll is paid the $83.3 millionOnly after appeals end; the bond covers the amount meanwhile

Plain-English example (made-up numbers, for illustration): When someone loses a big civil verdict and appeals, they usually post a bond, like a security deposit held by an insurer. Say a jury awards $1 million and the loser appeals. They post a bond a little higher than $1 million to cover interest. If they win the appeal, the bond is released. If they lose, the winner collects from the bond. That’s why Carroll was paid on the $5 million case after the Supreme Court said no, while the $83.3 million stays on hold.

Common mix-ups, cleared up

  • “Carroll was charged with a crime.” No. No charges against Carroll have been reported, and the Chicago U.S. attorney denied investigating her.
  • “The Supreme Court threw out both verdicts.” No. It declined to hear the $5 million appeal, which left that verdict standing. The $83.3 million petition is still waiting.
  • “This was a criminal trial.” No. Both cases were civil lawsuits. Trump was found liable, not guilty, and the penalty is money, not prison.
  • “The jury found Trump liable for rape.” The 2023 jury found sexual abuse under New York law, not rape as New York defined it then. The trial judge later said the finding was consistent with the common meaning of the word.
  • “The funding probe cancels the verdicts.” No. A verdict stands unless a court overturns it, whatever happens with the nonprofit inquiry.

What to watch next

  • Supreme Court order lists: A grant or denial on the $83.3 million petition could come any week during the term.
  • The Chicago inquiry: Any subpoenas, charges or a decision to close it.
  • Payment: If the Court denies review, Carroll could collect the $83.3 million plus interest from the bond.

FAQ

Is E. Jean Carroll under criminal investigation?

The U.S. attorney in Chicago said reports that his office opened an investigation into Carroll were false. Reports say the inquiry focuses on a Hoffman-backed nonprofit that helped fund her lawsuits. No charges have been reported.

Has Trump paid E. Jean Carroll?

Carroll was reported to have collected about $5.6 million, including interest, on the $5 million verdict after the Supreme Court declined Trump’s appeal in June 2026. The $83.3 million award is on hold while the Supreme Court considers Trump’s petition.

What did the Supreme Court decide in the Carroll case?

On June 29, 2026, it declined to hear Trump’s appeal of the $5 million verdict, leaving it in place. It hasn’t yet acted on the $83.3 million petition filed in July.

Why is the Justice Department involved?

The department argues the U.S. government should replace Trump as the defendant in the $83.3 million case under the Westfall Act, which covers federal employees acting within their jobs. Separately, prosecutors in Chicago reportedly looked into the nonprofit funding issue.

What is the $83.3 million verdict for?

A 2024 jury found Trump defamed Carroll with statements he made as president in 2019. The total included $18.3 million in compensatory damages and $65 million in punitive damages.

Bottom line

Carroll’s $5 million win is final and paid. Her $83.3 million win is waiting on the Supreme Court. The Justice Department probe reported in May is about a nonprofit that funded her lawyers, not a charge against Carroll, and it hasn’t produced any public charges. We’ll update this page when the Court acts.

Last reviewed: Oct. 26, 2026.

Sources: CNBC (June 29, 2026); SCOTUSblog; SCOTUSblog: $83.3 million petition; Bloomberg Law; NPR via Texas Public Radio (May 29, 2026); AP via KRDO.

Featured image: The U.S. Supreme Court building at dusk. Photo: Joe Ravi / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0; edited by Nexgen Headlines.

Get our free weekly money email

One email every Friday: the week's best US money tips, deals and consumer guides. Free, and you can unsubscribe anytime.

No spam, ever. Read our privacy policy for more info.

E. Jean Carroll vs. Trump in 2026: Verdicts, Appeals and the DOJ Probe Explained

Oh hi there 👋
It’s nice to meet you.

Sign up to receive awesome content in your inbox, every month.

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

Get one money-saving tip a day
Follow Nexgen Headlines on Facebook for Medicare, credit, travel and bill-saving guides.
Follow on Facebook
Share This Article
Senior Editor
Follow:
Saroj Mali is a senior editor at Nexgen Headlines, covering U.S. news, streaming and entertainment, and shopping deals. Saroj writes explainers that answer readers' practical questions, such as what changed, what it costs and what to do next, and compares streaming services and products by real prices and plan details. Every article is checked against official sources such as company announcements, government agencies and court records, and is updated when facts change. Readers can reach Saroj through the Contact page.